Residents across Lebanon are still feeling the pinch of the economic crisis, as consumer confidence drops for the second time this year, according to the latest Consumer Confidence Index (CCI). The Consumer Confidence Index, a quarterly survey conducted by the Middle East’s number one job site – Bayt.com in conjunction with research specialists YouGov, found that Lebanon moved down the index by0.7 points – the only country that reported a drop this quarter.
The survey showed that respondents felt certain features of their economic positions were unchanged from the previous year. More than a third of respondents,34%, felt that they were in the same financial position as last year, while the same number agreed that their country’s economy was unchanged. Unsurprisingly, respondents are optimistic about the future. Almost half of respondents,48%, said that they believe business conditions will be better, and40% said they think their country’s economy will improve in a year’s time.
Across the rest of the Middle East, consumer confidence levels showed a positive increase. Confidence in Kuwait rose by10.0 points and in the UAE by9.3 points; as in the previous wave, Kuwait and the UAE retain the two top spots in terms of improved confidence. While Qatar followed with a strong increase of9.0 points, the picture around the rest of the Gulf varied, with an increase of5.1 points in Bahrain and3.4 in Saudi Arabia. Syria showed a significant improvement of5.6 points.
In North Africa, Egypt and Morocco topped the table in terms of improved consumer confidence, moving up7.7 and6.7 points respectively, contrasted with a move up the index of just2.6 points in Algeria.
The Consumer Confidence Index is a measure of consumer expectations and satisfaction with various elements of the economy including inflation, job opportunities and the cost of living.
“While we are not seeing massive jumps up the index, the data shows that there are steady improvements, which reflects what is being reported and felt in economies around the region – namely that things are starting to pick up,” commented Amer Zureikat, Bayt.com’s Regional Manager. “Improvements in the index have been seen in countries in the Middle East for around six months now, so the real test as to whether consumer confidence is being sustained and improved as a result of the easing of the recession will become evident over the next year or so.”
The CCI is in part gauged by asking the respondents about their personal financial situation, and whether they feel that they are better, or worse off than12 months ago. In Lebanon,24% of respondents said they are better off than last year, while30% of respondents said they were worse off.
Around the region, respondents in Qatar recorded the most positive improvements in their financial positions:35% stated their position was better than last year. The other countries in the GCC reported slight improvements in personal finances:29% in KSA and26% in Bahrain stated they were better off. In line with the results of the last wave, respondents in the UAE and Jordan were hardest hit in terms of their personal finances, with40% and39% respectively stating they are worse off.
Consumer confidence is also assessed by asking the respondents about their consumer expectations and their level of optimism towards the future. While not such a huge increase as in the previous wave, consumer expectations improved in each of the surveyed countries with the exception of Lebanon, which stayed the same. As in the previous wave, the UAE was the country that improved the most, moving up the Consumer Expectations Index (CEI) by8.6 points, closely followed by Qatar, which moved up by8.3 points. Kuwait also followed suit, with an improvement of7.0 points. Bahrain and Saudi Arabia showed the lowest improvements among the GCC countries, moving up5.1 and3.1 points respectively.
In North Africa and the Levant, Egypt improved the most in terms of consumer expectations, moving up by6.1 index points, closely followed by Syria at5.4 points and Algeria at4.0.
Optimism for the future was found to reign supreme with many of the region’s respondents. Almost half of respondents,46%, said that their personal financial position would change for the better in a year’s time, and only8% said that it would be worse. Lebanon’s respondents were only slightly below the average, with43% stating their position would be better. Most optimistic among those surveyed were respondents in Bahrain:52% said their finances would be better after a year.
Respondents also felt positive that their country’s economy would improve in a year’s time;40% said that it will be better, compared to just19% of those that said it would become worse. While Kuwait topped the table –51% of respondents said their economy will be better – the UAE was also near the top:49% stated that things will be better. Respondents in Saudi Arabia and Qatar were similarly positive,47% and46% expected things to be better after a year, contrasted with35% of respondents in Lebanon who anticipated an improvement.
When asked whether it is a good time to buy consumer durables or not, respondents once again stated they are reluctant to spend:42% said it was a bad time to buy goods such as televisions or refrigerators,30% said it was a neutral time, while a fifth agreed that it was a good time to buy.
The survey showed that the propensity to consume index (PCI) varied from country to country. Moving highest up the PCI by13.2 index points was the UAE, highlighting a second significant improvement after the country’s jump of12.6 index points in the previous wave. Kuwait and Qatar also showed significant improvements in propensity to consume, moving up the index11.1 and9.4 points respectively. Unlike the previous wave when it showed an improvement, Algeria moved down the index by5.1 index points – the largest decrease among the surveyed countries. In this wave, Lebanon, which previously witnessed a drop, moved up the index by3.0 points as did Syria by2.3 points.
“The results show that while customers feel they are in a better financial position, they are still reluctant to part with their money for higher-end consumer items, which suggests that consumers are being cautious – perhaps until economic improvements look as though they are here to stay. In that regard, this data can serve as a useful milestone to measure the changes in consumer spending habits over time,” said Joanna Longworth, Chief Marketing Officer, YouGov.
The Employee Confidence Index (ECI) is a general measure of how people feel about the local job market and highlights their current attitudes towards availability of jobs and salary satisfaction. Showing the most improvements were Qatar and Syria, which moved up by10.6 and9.6 points respectively. The picture around the Gulf was also positive: Kuwait, Bahrain and the UAE moved up by6.8,6.1 and6.0 index points respectively, while Saudi Arabia showed a less remarkable increase of2.1 points. As in the previous wave, Lebanon saw a drop in employee confidence, this time by a higher2.0 index points, while Algeria moved down by1.3 points. The rest of the surveyed countries all showed improvements.
“In general, the employee confidence index shows that employees feel that their respective labour markets are picking up, with the exception of Lebanon and Algeria. This suggests that recessionary pressures are still being played out in those economies,” commented Longworth. “This data, coupled with ongoing news reports of the global economic downturn coming to an end, suggests that conditions are already better for employees in general.”
Following on from improvements in the previous wave, a greater proportion of respondents believe that more jobs will be available in a year’s time. Just28% of all respondents said they feel that job availability will be worse, compared to33% in the last wave; while30% of respondents said conditions would be better. Feeling most positive about the future availability of work were respondents in Qatar (43%), Kuwait (42%) and the UAE (40%) who said things would be better after a year. Those feeling pessimistic about the future availability of work were respondents in Egypt and Jordan:34% in each country said job availability would be worse after a year. In Lebanon, just18% of respondents believe there will be more jobs available in a year’s time.
As in previous waves, respondents feel that salary increases have not kept pace with the cost of living. The majority,60%, said that they haven’t kept pace, while17% feel they have increased in line with the cost of living.
“Conducting quarterly surveys to gauge levels of consumer confidence presents us with indications about how people are really feeling about many consumer confidence indicators; from whether they consider their salary to be sufficient, how positive they are feeling about the future and whether they feel they are in a position to spend money,” stated Zureikat.
“We therefore want to use this data to enable regional businesses, HR professionals and other relevant industry stakeholders to be up-to-the-minute with these market trends. Taking a purposive approach to the data will ultimately serve to benefit the businesses or organisations of those that use it – enabling them, for example, to retain customers or keep employees happy. In so doing, these steps could prove vital to their organisations’ health in the long term.”
Data for the August/September2009 Consumer Confidence Index Survey was collected online between17 August and8 September2009 with9,430 respondents from the UAE, KSA, Qatar, Oman, Kuwait, Bahrain, Syria, Jordan, Lebanon, Egypt, Morocco, Tunisia, Algeria and Pakistan. Males and females aged over18 years old, of all nationalities, were included in the survey.